Jiu jitsu its only gay if you make eye contact

This paper obtained a single peer review comment which was absolutely correct and had the failures of the paper dead to rights. The character of masculinity within GBMA, then, has significant cultural importance. These sports and the masculinities they promote are therefore increasingly influential to men, masculinity, and masculinity discourses in contemporary culture.

English In particular, I therefore aim to identify and unravel the myriad and unique factors within GBMA masculinity that evoke in participants so much interest in simulated violence and exclusion of that which they do not deem sufficiently masculine cf.

In that this was our first hoax paper, it was written as a true hoax: we cited at random, did not attempt to understand the relevant material, and made extraordinarily ridiculous claims and arguments. Hirose and Pih Throughout its history, martial arts participants have formed a unique subculture that is distinctly masculine, even hyper-masculine, and often performatively toxic.

An understanding of this dynamic within GBMA reveals its parallels with marginalized homosexual masculinities, and offers the potential to shift it toward greater openness, honesty, and inclusion. Regardless of sympathies to the thesis of the paper, its hoax-bases shortcomings were obvious to the reviewer showing that peer review does operate in these fields and that the problem is the worldview of the peers, not their competence as pseudo-academics.

This masculine subculture erupted from a fairly recent surge beginning c. It explores the dynamics of the regulation of touch and its consequences for primarily male bodies by focusing on the link between bodily practice in BJJ and the interpretation and representation of the aesthetics of that practice.

If correct, the purpose of this investigation is therefore ultimately to expose and disrupt the forces that constrain GBMA masculinity and prevent it from finding a healthier, nonviolent, inclusive masculine expression. Atlas Jiu Jitsu is a full MMA and Brazilian Jiu Jitsu School with locations in Gl.

Dutkiewicz J and Spencer DC () “It’s only gay if you make eye contact.” In: Sparkes, AC (ed.) Seeking the Senses in Physical Culture: Sensuous Scholarship in Action. Because of its profoundly gendered nature, the cultural impact of GBMA masculinity on marginalized masculine identities and women mirrors a problematic and toxic trendline for masculinity as it manifests in society.

I will attempt to do the same today on a subject just as important as any technique or concept in the sport – homosexuality in Jiu Jitsu. There's an old joke "It's only gay if you make eye contact", which really should be "rolling is only sexual if you make eye contact." Seriously, try it: next time you roll, look deeply into your partner's eyes; yuck!.

This paper critically examines the strain of masculinity unique to GBMA drawing on psychoanalytic approaches and reveals it to be best understood as an overt manifestation of phallic masculinity that is extended toward the hypermasculine by a homoerotic-yet-homophobic tension predicated upon performative homosociality and symbolic homosexuality.

Homosexuality in Jiu Jitsu

The so-called warrior class represents a cultural archetype of masculinity and many discourses in masculinity are defined either in reference or deference to it Channon b. Similar to all masculinity projects, grappling based martial arts participants are constrained by hegemonic forces shaping masculinities, particularly heteronomativity, machismo, female exclusion, and a marked interest and propensity toward violence.

“It’s Only Gay if You Make Eye Contact” This is a sentence most people involved in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu have heard and possibly said themselves. Mixed martial arts contains its own unique subculture, equipped with a variety of gendered values, norms, and attitudes which have developed over time.

Atlas Jiu Jitsu's Technique Of The Week with Edward "Scissorhands" Anthony. I have as well, repeated it as part of the culture. PDF Download. Brazilian Jiu Jitsu and mixed martial arts constitute two strongly overlapping, culturally influential communities composed mostly of men who enact a particular strain of masculinity through participation in grappling-based martial arts GBMA.

Indeed, the UFC alone represents a multi-billion-dollar brand in an even larger industry with tremendous commercial and popular appeal. Brazilian Jiu Jitsu BJJ and mixed martial arts MMA are two overlapping, culturally influential communities composed mostly of men who enact a defined strain of masculinity through grappling based martial arts henceforth, GBMA.

This chapter considers how broader normative discourses regarding sexuality and masculinity as well as biopolitical practices impinge on Brazilian Jiu Jitsu (BJJ). National and international competitions, tens of millions of participants worldwide, and the famous Ultimate Fighting Championship UFC acted in concert to promote these sports and their competitors to unprecedented status.

It is my hope that this analysis is not merely explanatory but that it extends into the realm of praxis by potentially creating opportunities for a more inclusive and diverse GBMA cultural environment cf. Specifically, GBMA masculinity can be understood as strict phallic masculinity expanded to include symbolic expressions of violence as a hegemonic masculinity-approved vent for repressed male-on-male homosexual desires and behavior in the absence of socially sanctioned opportunities for healthy male-on-male touch.

In the name of Richard Baldwin, Ph. This idea was building off a surprising body of literature that argued similar things for other sports.